The Chemistry of Electrolytes · Episode 05

Why not just put salt in your water?

It's a fair question. Salt is cheap, it's already in your pantry, and it gives you sodium. So what does a mix add?

Short answer. Salt water works for sodium. But table salt has almost no potassium or magnesium. Every cell in your body runs a pump that uses all three. Salt water brings one of them.

Rawstone Learn · general education, not medical advice

Salt water does one job well

Table salt is sodium chloride. About 39% of it, by weight, is sodium. A bit under half a level teaspoon (about 2.6g) gives you roughly 1,000mg of sodium.

That is a real dose. If sodium is all you want, salt water does the job. It costs almost nothing.

The catch is what it leaves out. A level teaspoon of table salt has under 1mg of potassium and under 0.1mg of magnesium. That is next to zero.

2.6g table salt One Rawstone serve Sodium ~1,000mg 1,000mg Potassium under 1mg 250mg Magnesium under 0.1mg 75mg One scale for all bars. Table salt: USDA FoodData Central.
Same sodium. Salt water is missing the other two.

The pump in every cell

Every cell in your body has tiny pumps in its wall. This one is called the sodium-potassium pump. A Danish scientist, Jens Skou, found it in 1957. He later won a Nobel Prize for it.

Each cycle, the pump pushes three sodium out of the cell and pulls two potassium in. That keeps sodium high outside the cell and potassium high inside. Those two levels set up the charge your nerves and muscles send their signals on.

Diagram of a cell wall with the sodium-potassium pump. Three sodium ions sit outside the cell, labelled 3 Na out. Two potassium ions sit inside, labelled 2 K in
Three sodium out, two potassium in, every cycle.

Its fuel needs magnesium

The pump runs on ATP, the fuel your cells make. But ATP doesn't work on its own. In the body, it works bound to magnesium, as a pair called Mg-ATP.

Diagram of the pump with ATP bound to a magnesium ion, labelled Mg-ATP. Sodium sits on both sides of the wall. Plus signs outside the cell wall and minus signs inside show the charge
ATP bound to magnesium fires the pump. Plus outside, minus inside.

So the pump uses three minerals: sodium, potassium and magnesium. Salt water brings one.

Could you make your own full mix?

You could. You would need salt, a potassium powder, a magnesium powder and a kitchen scale that weighs to a tenth of a gram. Then you would need to like the taste. Plain potassium and magnesium salts are bitter, and salt water is, well, salty water.

DIY salt waterA measured mix
CostWins. Cents a glassMore per serve
Already in the pantryWinsYou have to buy it
SweetenerNone at allMost use one
Potassium + magnesiumAlmost noneWins. In the same scoop
Same dose every timeDepends on your teaspoonWins. Measured
TasteSalty waterWins. Flavoured

If you only want sodium and don't mind the taste, salt water is a fine choice. If you want all three in one measured scoop, a mix saves you the scale.

New to sodium numbers? Start with the science of salt and hydration and how much salt you lose in sweat. Worried about the dose? Read is 1000mg of sodium too much? And on the magnesium form, see magnesium citrate vs oxide.

Where Rawstone fits

Rawstone is an Australian-owned, sugar-free hydration powder. Each 7g serve has 1,000mg sodium, plus the two minerals salt water leaves out: 250mg potassium (as citrate) and 75mg magnesium (as citrate). Mix one scoop into 750ml of water. One serve a day. Launching on Amazon Australia this summer.

See the product

Get the Sodium & Hydration Cheat Sheet + a launch-day discount

Sweat rates, sodium numbers and simple checks on one page. No spam.

Can I just put salt in my water?
Yes, for sodium. A bit under half a level teaspoon of table salt gives about 1,000mg of sodium. It gives you almost no potassium or magnesium.
How much salt gives 1,000mg of sodium?
About 2.6g of table salt, a bit under half a level teaspoon. Salt is about 39% sodium, and a level teaspoon holds about 6g.
Does table salt have potassium or magnesium?
Next to none. A level teaspoon of table salt has under 1mg of potassium and under 0.1mg of magnesium.
Is sea salt or pink salt better?
They carry small traces of other minerals, but they are still almost all sodium chloride. You would need a lot of salt to get a useful amount of potassium or magnesium from them.

Sources

  1. Skou JC. The influence of some cations on an adenosine triphosphatase from peripheral nerves. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta. 1957;23(2):394–401. doi:10.1016/0006-3002(57)90343-8
  2. de Baaij JHF, Hoenderop JGJ, Bindels RJM. Magnesium in man: implications for health and disease. Physiological Reviews. 2015;95(1):1–46. doi:10.1152/physrev.00012.2014
  3. Alberts B, et al. Molecular Biology of the Cell, 4th ed. Carrier proteins and active membrane transport. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  4. U.S. Department of Agriculture. FoodData Central: Salt, table. fdc.nal.usda.gov

By Tom Bolger, Rawstone founder. Tom works in beverage manufacturing and trains in the gym most days. He started Rawstone because he wanted a full-strength hydration powder he would actually drink every day.

This article is general education about hydration, not medical advice. Rawstone is a formulated supplementary sports food, not a medicine, and is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Consume no more than one serve a day. If you have a condition that means you need to manage your sodium, potassium or fluid intake, talk to your doctor before using any high-sodium product.